Would You Rather Halloween Game

Treat your party to a round of this Would You Ever Halloween game. It's a fang-tastic way to get your guests talking and laughing.

Would You Rather Halloween Question

There are a few ways this game can be played. The easiest way to play is to read dilemmas out loud and then have your guests vote by a show of hands on whether they choose A or B.  

This can lead to some interesting conversations, but it also helps friends and strangers get to know each other better, so it's a win all around.

Would Your Rather Halloween Game Questions

If you want to play for points and prizes, either print a card copy or a list copy of the questions below.

  1. Would you rather (A) live in Transylvania or (B) live in Sleepy Hollow?

  2. Would you rather (A) wear a spooky costume or (B) dress up like a celebrity?

  3. Would you rather (A) carve a pumpkin or (B) bake a pumpkin pie?

  4. Would you rather (A) watch a scary movie or (B) tell a ghost story?

  5. Would you rather (A) visit a haunted house or (B) go on a hayride?

  6. Would you rather (A) go to a Halloween party or (B) pass out candy at home?

  7. Would you rather (A) decorate your house for Halloween or (B) set a Thanksgiving table?

  8. Would you rather (A) paint your face or (B) wear a mask?

  9. Would you rather (A) cast spells or (B) make wishes come true?

  10. Would you rather (A) be able to read minds or (B) see the future?

  11. Would you rather (A) do the Monster Mash or (B) dance to Michael Jackson's Thriller?

  12. Would you rather (A) sleep in a room with spiders or (B) sleep in a cave with bats?

  13. Would you rather (A) fly on a witch's broom or (B) take a magic carpet ride?

  14. Would you rather (A) eat mealworms or (B) eat fried crickets?

  15. Would you rather (A) be a Ghostbuster or (B) be a mummy embalmer?

Would You Rather Halloween Game Pin

Instructions for Would You Rather Halloween Game Card Version

  • Print and cut out the question cards.

  • If you print the questions on card stock you can simply stack them face down in the center of the play area. If you print them on paper then it would be best to fold the questions and place them in a bowl or basket.

  • Print the numbered score sheets (one per guest). Be sure you have enough pens or pencils available for guests to record scores during the game.

  • Choose a guest to begin the game and then move left or right. Your choice.  

  • The first guest draws a question card and reads it aloud. Both the reader and the other players record their choice on the score sheet without showing anyone their choice.


NOTE: You can decide before starting the game whether you want players to answer the questions as themselves or whether the players must try and guess what the readers answer will be.

  • Once everyone has made their choice, the reader reveals their answer. If no one answered the question the same as the reader, the reader gets 3 points. If anyone chose the same answer, the reader gets zero points and anyone who answered the same as the reader gets one point.

  • This continues around the circle till there are no cards left or until everyone has had a turn or two depending on the number of guests attending.

  • At the end, points are tallied and the person with the highest score either gets bragging rights or a prize.

Would You Rather Halloween Game ListWould You Rather Halloween Game List


Instructions For Would You Rather Halloween Game List Version

  • Print a Would You Rather list page for each guest.

  • Have guests record their choice for each of the questions.

  • Choose a guest to begin the game and then move left or right. 

  • The first guest shares their answer to the first question. 

  • If no one answered the question the same as them, he/she gets 3 points. If anyone chose the same answer, he/she gets zero points and anyone who answered the same as that guest gets one point.

  • This continues around the circle till all of the questions have been scored.

  • At the end, points are tallied and the person with the highest score either gets bragging rights or a prize.

Other Game Play Options: 

If it's someone's birthday or there is a guest of honor at the party, they could be the sole reader and guests answers would need to match theirs to score.

You could also just read the questions and get everyone's answers just for fun.

Print the Game

For your free printable Would You Rather Halloween game list, game cards and score cards, fill in the form below. You'll get immediate access. 

Note that there are 3 printables. Be sure to download the one(s) you want to use, so you'll be ready to play when your party begins.

Would You Rather Halloween Game Printables
Please note that all fields followed by an asterisk must be filled in.


Recent Articles

RSS

  1. Bridal Shower Apron Game

    May 01, 24 03:37 PM

    Bride Decked Out in Kitchen Gadgets for a Bridal Shower Apron Game
    Dress up the bride in an apron and kitchen utensils for this bridal shower apron game. She's sure to get a few giggles as she tests the guests memories.

    Read More

  2. Neighborhood Scavenger Hunt

    Apr 24, 24 04:43 PM

    Cozy Residential Location for a Neighborhood Scavenger Hunt
    Ideas to plan a neighborhood scavenger hunt. Use your own neighborhood to set up the hunt or find another quaint or interesting neighborhood to explore.

    Read More

  3. Girls Spa Theme Slumber Party

    Apr 24, 24 03:19 PM

    Spa Theme Slumber Party Manicures
    Ideas for a spa themed slumber party for girls, including 11 diy temporary tattoo ideas, slumber party games, and a homemade chocolate body scrub recipe

    Read More

Show / Hide